Building a Website With AI Is Easy. Building a Business That Works for You & Gets Found Isn’t.

The hidden costs of vibe coding, AI website builders and skipping professional expertise.

Creating a website has never been easier. Open Lovable or another AI website builder, describe your business, choose a few colours, and within minutes you can have something that looks like a functioning website. No coding skills. No designer. No agency. And at a fraction of the cost. For small business owners watching every pound, that’s incredibly appealing. I completely understand why.

But there’s a question that often gets overlooked:

Just because you can build a website, does that mean you know how to build one that actually works for your business?

And by works, I don’t just mean a website that loads when you click the link. I mean a website that people can find, understand, trust and ultimately use to become paying customers. That’s where things become more complicated.

The problem isn’t AI. It’s the illusion that the difficult part has disappeared.

I’m a big believer in AI. I use it in my work, and I think tools like Lovable are genuinely impressive. They make technology more accessible. They help people experiment, test ideas and create things that would previously have been too expensive or complicated. That’s a good thing.

But they also create an illusion: that building the website was the hard part.

For most small businesses, it wasn’t.

The difficult part is understanding who your customers are, what they’re searching for, what makes them choose one business over another, and how to turn that understanding into an effective online experience.

AI can build what you ask for. It doesn’t automatically know what your business actually needs.

And if you don’t have experience in marketing, SEO, user experience or web development, how do you know whether what it’s created is any good?

Welcome to the world of AI slop

You’ve probably seen these websites already. The same oversized headlines. The same gradients. The same stock-style imagery. The same three feature boxes. The same vague promises about quality, passion and exceptional service. Different businesses. Almost identical websites.

This is what people increasingly call AI slop: content and design produced quickly, with little originality, direction or meaningful human judgement.

It’s not that AI cannot create beautiful, distinctive websites. It absolutely can. The problem is what happens when everyone gives it roughly the same instructions: “Create a modern, professional website for my business.”

The result might look polished at first glance. But where’s the personality? What makes the business memorable? Why should someone choose it over a competitor?

A good website should feel like an extension of the business behind it. A family-run bakery in Edinburgh shouldn’t have the same personality as a Glasgow-based IT consultancy. And yet, without proper creative direction, that’s exactly the kind of uniformity these tools can produce.

Your brand shouldn’t look like a prompt someone else typed five minutes ago.

A beautiful website that nobody finds is an expensive business card

This is perhaps the biggest misunderstanding I encounter when discussing websites with small business owners. People focus heavily on what their website looks like. And of course, design matters. But imagine you’ve opened a new café in Edinburgh. You generate a lovely website with an AI builder. It has photos, a menu, opening hours and a contact page. You publish it. Now what?

Will it appear when someone searches for “breakfast near me” or “independent café in Edinburgh”? Does it have pages targeting the searches that matter to your business? Is it connected to your Google Business Profile? Does its content explain your offering in language your customers actually use? Are its pages structured correctly, indexable and useful to search engines? Does it load quickly on mobile? Can someone find the menu, book a table or get directions without frustration? These things don’t automatically happen because a website looks good.

And this matters even more as search evolves beyond traditional Google results towards AI-powered discovery. To be fair, platforms like Lovable now include SEO tools, technical audits and search integrations. That’s useful progress.

But having access to SEO tools is not the same as having an SEO strategy.

An audit can identify a missing page title. It cannot independently decide which customers you should prioritise, how to position your business against local competitors or what makes your service worth choosing. Google doesn’t reward a website simply because it was built by a professional, nor penalise it simply because AI was used. What matters is whether the website is technically accessible and provides useful, relevant, original content and a good experience for visitors. That requires more than generating pages.

The real problems often start after launch

Here’s another scenario. You’ve created your website using prompts. Everything looks good. You’re feeling confident. A few months later, your business grows. You want to introduce a booking system, redesign the services section, change the navigation and add some new functionality. So you write another prompt. The AI makes changes. Except now the mobile menu behaves strangely. The booking form isn’t working as expected. Some layouts have changed, and you’re not entirely sure what happened. You try another prompt to fix it. Then another. And another. Suddenly, something that was supposed to make your life easier has become frustrating and time-consuming.

Modern AI builders often provide version history and recovery options. Lovable, for example, lets users restore previous versions of their code. But reversing a code change doesn’t necessarily reverse changes to stored data or repair every external integration. The real issue is knowing what went wrong, why it happened and how to fix it safely.

When you don’t understand the underlying website, you’re dependent on the tool to explain and repair its own work. And when that isn’t enough, you start looking for a developer. Someone who now needs to understand a project they didn’t build, diagnose the problems, assess the quality of the existing work and decide what can be saved. Sometimes it’s a straightforward fix. Other times, correcting the problems takes more work than building the website properly in the first place. Suddenly, the cheapest option isn’t looking quite so cheap.

You’re not paying a professional to press buttons

This is where I think the conversation about website pricing needs to change. When you hire an experienced web designer, developer or digital marketing specialist, you’re not simply paying for the hours it takes to assemble some pages. You’re paying for the decisions made before, during and after the build. You’re paying for someone who knows which questions to ask. Someone who can challenge an idea that sounds good but won’t work for your customers. Someone who understands how people navigate websites, where they hesitate, why they leave and what encourages them to take action. Someone who can connect design, branding, content, search visibility, performance and commercial objectives. And importantly, someone who knows what to do when something goes wrong. The value isn’t in knowing how to add a button. It’s knowing whether that button needs to be there, what it should say, where it should lead and how to measure whether it’s achieving anything.

A website isn’t just a design project. It’s a marketing and business development tool.

That expertise doesn’t disappear because a new tool can generate code in seconds.  If anything, the ability to produce websites faster makes professional judgement more valuable.

The cheapest website isn’t always the most affordable

I understand why a small business might hesitate before investing £1,000, £2,000 or more in a professional website. That’s real money, especially when you’re just starting out. But the initial build cost is only part of the equation.

There’s also the cost of your time.
The cost of fixing unexpected problems.
The cost of having a website that doesn’t appear for relevant searches.
The cost of confusing potential customers, losing enquiries or having to rebuild everything six months later.

Imagine two businesses.

One spends very little on a website but never develops a clear marketing strategy, rarely receives enquiries and eventually needs substantial technical help. The other invests more carefully in a website designed around specific business objectives, with a clear structure, local SEO foundations and an ongoing improvement plan.

Neither is guaranteed success.

But the second business has made a more deliberate investment in how its website will support growth. And that’s the difference worth thinking about. Don’t just ask how much a website costs to build. Ask what it will cost to run, maintain and make useful to your business.

So, should small businesses avoid Lovable and AI website builders?

Absolutely not. For a simple landing page, an early-stage business idea, an event website or a quick prototype, these tools can be excellent. Some businesses can build perfectly good websites with them, especially when the person creating the site understands design, marketing and the technical requirements. And professionals should be embracing these tools too.

There’s no reason to spend hours manually doing something that AI can help accomplish in minutes. But saving time on production shouldn’t mean removing the thinking, planning, testing and expertise that make a project successful. The smart approach isn’t necessarily choosing between AI and a professional. It’s understanding how the two can work together.

AI can reduce the cost of production. A professional can help make sure that what gets produced is actually worth having.

A final thought from someone who builds websites for small businesses

At Rēkito Digital, I don’t believe every small business needs an expensive, complicated website. Quite the opposite. Often, a small, focused and well-structured website is far more effective than something filled with unnecessary pages, animations and features.

But I do believe every business deserves a website built with a purpose. One that reflects who they are. One that their customers can find. One that’s easy to use. One that can grow and evolve without becoming a technical nightmare. And one that’s backed by a clear understanding of marketing, search and customer behaviour.

The tools we use to build websites will keep changing. They’ll become faster, smarter and more affordable. That’s exciting. But knowing how to build something and knowing what is worth building are two very different skills.

AI can help you build a website. Experience helps you build the right one.

Need a website that does more than just look good?

I combine web design, SEO, digital marketing and AI to help small businesses build a stronger online presence. Whether you’re starting from scratch, improving an existing website or trying to understand why your current site isn’t bringing in customers, I can help you find the right approach without unnecessary complexity.

Explore my services and let’s have a chat